I’m really excited because I’ve decided to finish reading Michael Flynn’s
Eifelheim when
I get home today. I’m at about the half-way point in the book, but I’ve gotten
there by reading a page here or there. I haven’t really sat down and read a book
since I finished reading Spin.
That was also when I started reading Eifelheim.
It’s amazing how easy it is to get sucked into watching crappy television series
(like Smallville) or great television series (like The West Wing) instead. To just
collapse onto the couch, reach for a remote control, and have entertainment
spoon-fed into my mind is…well, easy. And don’t get me wrong: I’m not saying that
there’s anything wrong with easy entertainment. And certainly, shows like The West
Wing or Buffy or Firefly play with big ideas that are worth thinking about. Indeed,
those three transcend the bounds of trashy TV entertainment and enter the realm of
art. (And then there’s Smallville, which is dumb while still being enjoyable; but I keep
wondering what it would have been like if it had been done by Joss Whedon. Among
other things, I imagine that Lana would be a much stronger character and
not just wait around for Clark to save her all the time.)
But TV lacks something. And I don’t hold with the traditional reasons why books
are “better” than television. It’s not about imagination or thinking-skills or
superior dramatic presentation or anything like that.
Every episode of The West Wing challenges the viewer to think in some way. Its
dramatic presentation is often flawless and simply couldn’t be done without the
skills of the actors or directors or cinematographers. It just wouldn’t work in
book-form and I’m happier as a person to have seen it (and to own the DVDs so I
can watch it over and over again. I just finished season 3 again last night.).
As for imagination: don’t even try to tell me that a world where demons wage
war against a small suburban California town and a vampire-with-a-soul is in love
with the one woman in the world with both the power and mandate to kill him doesn’t
require quite a bit of imagination to deal with. The threshold for the suspension
of disbelief is so high that it simply requires one’s imagination to get a workout.
Indeed, this is true for any good sci-fi or fantasy. It’s easy to demonstrate too.
Just find the online communities of fans and watch how they invent new rules of
the fictional universe just to keep individual episodes consistent with one another.
And then, of course, there’s fanfic…
Too much TV doesn’t ask the viewer to think (*cough*DayTimeTV*cough*), but I don’t
like it when people judge the entire medium based on the flaws of the poorly
executed. So there’s that.
The something that TV lacks is the tactile nature of reading: The weight of the
book in my hands, the feel of the pages on my finger tips, the smell of the
paper, the sound of the turning pages, the elegance of well done typography.
These things combine to create an experience that’s completely unreproducible
in any other way. Everything else after that (owning the characters in my mind
in a way that I’ll never own Buffy or Mal or President Bartlet, creating a world
that’s unique to my imagination, etc.) is just gravy.
And that’s why I’m excited to be planning to go home tonight and leave the DVD
player off. I’ll turn on my reading light, sit down in a reasonably comfortable
char, and hold a good book in my hands. And despite all the turns my life has
taken, it will be truly good to be me.